I really loved how long they fizz once you drop them in the bath. If you've ever tried a bath bomb of any kind, you know it's hit-and-miss with how long they'll fizz. Some fizz for forever, and some just sort of fizzle (ha!) out. These bath fizzers lasted quite a while for me, which was great. I want to enjoy my baths, so it's nice to not have these just disintegrate once they're dropped into the bath.
I also loved that they were already separated into halves. Trust me, this is a great asset for these products. It's pretty much impossible to split a LUSH bath bomb in half, so the fact that these are already split is awesome.
Now, what I didn't really like about these bath fizzers: the scents. They're SO. STRONG. And not really a good strong. There's some scent in all of them that just does not sit well with me or my nose. I'm not exactly sure what it is, since One doesn't list the specific fragrances of any of their bath fizzers. Honestly, I must be allergic to it or something, because that's the only thing I can smell when I smell any of these bath fizzers. This is probably just me, though, so I strongly suggest you go do a sniff test for yourself.
Note: One does have one more bath fizzer, I Need This!, which is a lemongrass pick-me-up. I'd love to smell this one, since I adore lemongrass.
(Disclaimer: I received this product for free from One Bath and Body. The opinions stated above are completely my own and have not been influenced by anyone in any way.)